The method on one page

Every market is read the same way. Seven questions; four of them scored; six factors weighed into one grade; the result carried onto every brief and tool.

Full methodology → ·

1

Seven questions

Asked of every market, in this order. The dark four are scored.

1SupplyWhat exists, who has it
2DemandWho buys, for what
3ConcentrationWho sets the price
4LiquidityCan a unit be sold
5ScarcityCan supply respond
6ProvenanceIs it what it says
7Price formationHow it all combines
↓
2

Four scores

Each 1 to 5 with a band word. Never added together.

Concentration
1 Low5 High
5 when the top three control three-quarters of the price-setting stage
Liquidity
1 Low5 High
5 when an exchange or daily reference price exists and clears daily
Scarcity
1 Low5 High
5 when supply is fixed or falling and cannot expand in five years
Provenance risk
1 Low5 High
5 when mislabelling exceeds a fifth, or no independent check exists
↓
3

One grade

Six factors, each 1 to 5, weighed into ΣΟΦΙΑ's opinion of how practical the asset is to own and sell. Not a view on return.

Valuationhow independently priced
Exithow fast, at what cost
Custodywhat keeping it needs
Title and transferhow ownership moves
Accesswho can buy at all
Intangible premiumhow much is story
→
ΣA judgement across the six, not an average
Σ5Institutional3
Σ4Accessible7
Σ3Specialist19
Σ2Restricted19
Σ1No route2
↓
4

Where it appears

The same values, dated and versioned, everywhere they are used.

Market briefGrade, four scores, six factors, horizon and exit, with sourcesGold, for example →
CompareAll 50 markets on the four scoresCompare →
Start hereThe parts of a brief that bear on a decisionStart here →
Committee paperThe brief re-set for the file, with a reference IDBuild one →
Throughout

Rules of evidence

Every figure cited or absentNo live pricesDiscrepancies shown, not reconciledInference markedConfidence tagged High, Med, LowDated "Data as of"Corrections logged, never removedVersioned method

Methodology v1.2 · 3 Nov 2026 · Market intelligence and data, not investment advice.